NewsMay 13, 2014

How Low Will Summer Sea Ice Go? Ponds May Hold Key

By Andrea Thompson

Follow @AndreaTWeather

The spring Arctic sea ice melt is well underway, the ice contracting to cover a progressively smaller area until it eventually reaches its annual minimum extent at the end of the summer.

Arctic sea ice extent for April 2014 was 5.46 million square miles, 282,000 square miles below the 1981-to-2010 average (the magenta line).
Click image to enlarge. Credit: NSIDC


Although this year's melting has progressed in fits and starts, Arctic ice coverage has been below average since reaching its annual maximum in March, according to the latest update from the National Snow and Ice Data Center. It is unclear what this early spring extent will mean for the annual minimum in September, as models have proven to be poor at predicting unusual outcomes.

A new study has suggested, however, that projections might improve if the models took into account how much of the sea ice surface was covered in melt ponds, or the pools of water that collect on top of the ice as it melts. These pools reinforce the melt cycle because their blue depths absorb the sun’s rays, causing warming and further melt, while the bright white ice reflects the light.

The annual summer minimum is closely watched, in part, because although it is a normal part of the annual sea ice cycle, it has stood as a particularly stark marker of the steady decline in Arctic sea ice fueled by global warming. The changing ice patterns in the Arctic can influence circulation patterns in the ocean and the atmosphere, with effects potentially extending far outside of the polar realm.

Spring Extent

The sea ice of the Arctic hit its maximum extent for the year on March 21, peaking at 5.7 million square miles, some 282,000 square miles below the 1981-to-2010 average, after a late-season surge in ice formation. That area was the fifth lowest maximum in the satellite record, which goes back to 1978, an example of the trend in declining ice extents that comes with Arctic warming.RELATEDArctic Ice Hits Yearly Max, But Summer’s Melt Uncertain
Powerful Video of Record Arctic Sea Ice Melt
2013 Arctic Sea Ice Loss

The late surge in ice growth was followed by a rapid retreat in early April, before the rate of melt slowed later in the month. The average rate of decline in April was 11,700 square miles per day — roughly the combined size of Rhode Island and Massachusetts — slower than the average rate of 14,800 square miles per day during the 1981-to-2010 time period.

The average extent of the ice in April was 5.46 million square miles, 236,000 square miles below the average, but nearly 300,000 square miles above the record low for the month, set in 2007, according to the latest NSIDC data. The April 2014 extent was still small enough to also rank as the fifth lowest on record.

This plot shows Arctic sea ice extent through May 5, 2014, along with the extents over the same period from other recent years and the 1981 to 2010 average.
Click image to enlarge. Credit: NSIDC


But the condition of the ice now doesn’t seem to have a clear connection to its state at the end of the summer, at least not one that scientists have been able to suss out. Various models have been used to try to project the summer minimum, with fairly good results when that minimum fits within the long-term trend of decline. But when the minimum falls outside of those bounds, the models don’t see it coming, a study detailed in the journal Geophysical Research Letters earlier this year found.

Neither the extent nor the thickness of the sea ice at the end of the winter seems to correlate well with summer extent, according to the study. Co-author Julienne Stroeve, of the NSIDC, told Climate Central in April that this result shows how important the Arctic’s summer weather is in determining just how low the ice will go.

Melt Pond Projections

The new study, published online April 20 in the journal Nature Climate Change, may have found a way to improve the seasonal sea ice projections, though, by including those pools of meltwater.

Researchers used the aptly named CICE (“see-ice”) model to simulate the evolution of melt ponds (because good observations of the ponds are hard to come by) and looked at a statistical comparison between the melt pond area in May (when the ponds first form) and the summer ice extent. What they got was a  “surprisingly strong correlation,” study author David Schröder, of the University of Reading in England, told Climate Central. It was actually stronger than the correlation between the thickness of the spring ice (as thinner ice would be more susceptible to melt) and the summer minimum.

The dark teal waters of the melt ponds atop Arctic sea ice stand in stark contrast to the bright white of the ice and snow in this photo taken on July 12, 2011.
Credit: Kathryn Hansen/NASA


The strong correlation makes sense given the clear underlying feedback of meltwater absorbing solar radiation (increasing the albedo of the ice, in scientific parlance) and causing more melt, Schröder said. (The amount of melt pond coverage is also an indicator of the state of the ice in spring, as those ponds can cover more ground on relatively flat first-year ice, which is thinner because it has just formed, than on craggy older ice, which is typically thicker.)

“So certainly having an earlier melt onset and earlier melt pond formation helps to enhance the ice-albedo feedback that leads to more ice melted in the summer,” Stroeve wrote in an email. Though the summer weather is still a key factor in the eventual minimum extent.

Schröder’s team predicted that September 2013 would have an average ice extent of 5.55 million square kilometers, which ended up being closer to the observed extent of 5.35 million square kilometers than any of the 23 other competing predictions made by climate scientists (or, presumably, the informal pools some run to see who can pick the minimum extent).

Schröder said that his team will be making a prediction again for this year’s summer ice extent at the beginning of June based on the melt pond formation in May.

But to see what this summer brings for ice melt and the minimum extent (and who wins those pools), scientists, like everyone else, will just have to wait and see.

You May Also Like
Melt of Key Antarctic Glaciers ‘Unstoppable,’ Studies Find
Watch the Earth Live From Space, Music Not Included
Can We Talk About the New NCA Website?
John Allen: Scientist with an Eye on the Storm