News Section
Stories from Climate Central's Science Journalists and Content Partners

Ecosystems Face Unprecedented ‘Climate Change Velocity’

Repost This

Over the next century, plants and animals on land might be in for a wild and ultimately devastating ride. Warming temperatures, changing precipitation patterns, and extreme weather and climate events are likely to increase at a rate and magnitude not seen in more than 65 million years, according to a new study published Thursday in the journal Science.

Couple that with other human-related ecosystem disruptions, from highways to deforestation to pollution, and some species could find themselves pushed to the top of the mountain or the tip of a continent with no suitable habitat left in which to move.

A view of the Brazilian Amazon rainforest and a field that's been clearcut. Rising temperatures and land use changes will pose an unprecedented challenge to ecosystems across the globe.
Credit: CIAT International Center for Tropical Agriculture/Flickr

Global average surface temperatures have risen about twice as fast over land during the past century as they have over the ocean, a trend likely to continue into the next century. Based on the current emissions trajectory, temperatures are projected to rise by as much as 9°F over much of the Earth’s land, the study found. The last time the Earth warmed that much was around 55 million years ago. Only the cooling that caused the extinction of the dinosaurs tops the magnitude of change over the past 65 million years.

“The key difference is the rate of change,” said co-author Noah Diffenbaugh, a climate scientist and Senior Fellow at the Woods Institute for the Environment at Stanford University, in an interview. “The combination of rate and magnitude over the next century is unprecedented. In the context of the geological record of the last 65 million years, this (change in the 21st century) is likely to be an order of magnitude, or two or three orders, more rapid.”

When Earth warmed 55 million years ago, it did so over 10,000 years. The projected change over the next century provides a small window in which life on Earth, including humans, will need to adapt to a similar change in temperatures.

Average temperature change only tells part of the story, though. “One key aspect of this review is that extremes really are where a lot of the impact is felt,” Diffenbaugh said. “It’s not that another degree of global warming will impact ecosystems, it’s that those ecosystems will encounter extremes much more frequently.”

And those extremes can have profound impacts on ecosystems around the world. For example, in the Amazon, rainfall decreased by 3.2 percent each year from 1970 to 1998. That led to increased wildfires and tree die-offs throughout the region.

To cope with the changes, ecosystems will either need to adapt to the new normal or migrate to a more suitable habitat. Certain species are already responding. Shrubland has expanded throughout the Arctic in response to warmer conditions. In the Northeast U.S., certain plants bloomed 11 days earlier on average from 2000 to 2009 compared to 161 years ago, according to historical records.

Shrubland has increased in recent years throughout the Arctic.
Credit: kdee64/Flickr

The idea that species will move is informing a relatively new area of research known as “climate change velocity.” The basic premise rests on looking at expected changes over the next century in relation to the present, and then anticipating how far ecosystems would need to shift each year to stay in their comfort zone.

“If you look at how rapidly species would have to move in space to keep up with climate change, over many land areas species would have to move at a rate of at least a kilometer per year in order to maintain the annual temperature that they currently experience,” Diffenbaugh said. 

Some previous research has identified flat areas as where changes will happen the fastest because plants and animals will have to move greater distances to find the same conditions they’re used to. However, the new study shows that ecosystems in mountainous zones, such as the edge of South America and Africa, and high northern latitudes could have to travel the fastest and farthest to keep up with temperature change.

Species in those regions may have to move at a rate upwards of 80 miles a year in order to stay in areas with the same temperature they currently live with, according to the study. For species at the top of the mountain that are accustomed to a cooler climate, that could simply translate to nowhere to go or no path to get there.

While the high latitudes and mountains have the more eye-popping velocity of change numbers, Diffenbaugh warned that species in tropical areas, which are experiencing less of an absolute temperature change compared to the other regions, are still at risk in a warming world. That’s because species there are adapted to the relatively lower climate annual variability so even slight shifts in that range can have profound consequences.

“We’ve seen, for example in the Amazon, severe heat and severe drought have substantial impacts on forest ecosystems,” Diffenbaugh said. “There are examples of extreme events having substantial impacts on a yearly timescale.”

This past year, Australia experienced its hottest summer on record during which wildfires raged across the landscape.

The top map shows velocity of climate change estimates based on the new Science study. The bottom map shows velocity of climate change based on previous estimates. Note the two maps use different scales.
Credit: Diffenbaugh and Field, 2013

While using temperature to determine the velocity of change shows relatively clear consequences, Diffenbaugh acknowledged that the approach might oversimplify the issue. “In the paper, we review a number of other aspects of climate that can have impacts on ecosystems, including precipitation and extreme events such as heat waves, droughts, and severe storms,” he said. “The velocity question could be asked through a number of those lenses. That’s part of the active edge of this area of research.”

At the root of those future changes is the path humans take into the 21st century.

For example, the Energy Information Administration forecasts that fossil fuels will be the dominant source of energy through 2040, but allows for a number of uncertainties from economic growth to price spikes that could alter that trajectory.

Similarly, population growth, technological innovations, and policy changes could further change greenhouse gas emissions and, with it, what the future climate and its impact on ecosystems will look like.

Regardless, any warming will also take place in a world that’s increasingly fragmented by human development. Water and air pollution, urban sprawl, mining, deforestation, and other alterations to the landscape will create a steeplechase course for plants and animals to navigate in search of more hospitable climates.

How species deal with this confluence of changes in the coming century is uncertain. Terrestrial ecosystems faired well during the warming 55 million years ago, though they had much longer to adapt.

Michael Mann, a scientist at Penn State not affiliated with the study, said, “this study makes clear that we can expect unprecedented rates of warming, shifting rainfall and drought, that will challenge the adaptive capacity of life on Earth -- including human beings.”

Related Content
How Biodiversity Loss is Like Lebron James and the Miami Heat
Colombia's Cloud Forests Besieged by Climate Change
The Velocity of Climate Change

Comments

By Victoria (Oakland, CA)
on August 2nd, 2013

Nice summary of the Nature findings / reactions from other scientists. I wonder where and with what species we’re already seeing examples of this happening?

Reply to this comment

By Dave (Basking Ridge, NJ 07920)
on August 2nd, 2013

Velocities in the region of 10 km per year and in some regions even around 100 km year or so are so very much faster than those of previous estimates that I have seen and also the one comparison reported here in the maps. Adaptation pressure and consequent higher forcing of biodiversity loss was already a concern for velocities around 1km/yr.

There has been a lot of scientifically-based concern over the likelihood that another major mass extinction event has started and that it is gathering momentum. Projects such as the Noah’s Ark style, massive millennium seed bank project at Kew Gardens, UK, are testimony to the depth and seriousness of this concern. But as this situation progresses the solution gets further beyond the reach of customary and practical conservation and preservation efforts. Pressures on global ecosystems due to land use changes and climate change are generally known to be growing rapidly. This latest report though is at a whole different level and is sobering news – especially for apex species. Man is of course very highly adaptable. So maybe centuries from now mankind at least will survive and be living mostly on a diet of genetically engineered food-like substances made from something like sea grown algae. That prospect is not altogether inconceivable. But also one has to wonder just what the natural world at that time could be like.

Reply to this comment

By Chris Hudson (Arcadia CA 91006)
on September 23rd, 2013

What rising temperatures are you talking about? HadCRUT4 shows no warming for 18 years. HadCRUT3 for 19 years and NOAA’s troposphere measurments show no warming for 23 years. If the earth is warming uncontrollably, shouldn’t empirical temperature records show an upward trend? Temperatures have been trending dowward for over a decade. When did negative correlations become evidence of positive trends?
One theory says uncontrolled warming. Another says ever changing cyclical climate. No empirical evidence exists for the former. In fact, recent measurements show the opposite. Empirical temperature records exist to support the latter. Now, which one are we supposed to believe?
Oh, the one that claims lower temperatures are proof of warming, ok.

Reply to this comment

Name (required):
Email (required):
City/State/Zip:
Enter the word "climate" in the box below:

[+] View our comment guidelines.

Please note: Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment will not appear until reviewed by Climate Central staff. Thank you for your patience.